Baztab News

Editorial: Wringing hands in worry

07 Nov 2019 Afghanistan Times

A new Indian movie on the founder of the modern state of Afghanistan, Ahmad Shah Abdali Baba, focused on his third battle of Panipat has sparked concerns among Afghans. They are roiled as they view the film as an insult to the former heroic King because he is shown as a villain in the movie. The Panipat movie – the trailer of which has been recently released – supposedly depicts the battle of the same name that took place in 1761 between the Marathi Empire and Afghanistan. The battle of Panipat was won by Ahmad Shah Abdali wherein more than 50,000 Indian soldiers were killed; however, it is reported that the film shows the Marathas winning the historic war. The reason the trailer has come under fire is that the Bollywood films have established bad precedents of misrepresenting historical figures and traditions – e.g. the likes of Padmaavat – and such distortions have led to stirring controversies in the past. With Afghans’ concern of the movie being an affront to the dignity of Ahmad Shah Baba is well-reasoned – because after all, he is the hero of Afghans – these criticisms are premature considering the responses of the films’ cast who rejected any apprehensions regarding putting the Battle of Panipat out of proper historical perspective. Moreover, senior Bollywood actor Sanjay Dutt, who stars as Ahmad Shah Baba, has himself reportedly said that he wouldn’t have played the role if it had been bad – in spite of the fact that he tweeted: “Ahmad Shah Abdali – Death strikes where his shadow falls.” Besides, the movie also features an Afghan actor from Paktika province, Babrak Akbari, who plays the role of a loyal guard of Sanjay Dutt (Abdali Baba). He has said the movie was based on real history. “If it contained anything against Afghanistan, I would have never worked in it.” The filmmakers and director of the movie have also assured Afghan envoys that it portrays historical facts, and nothing else. There are apprehensions that in case the film insulted the Afghan hero, it would harm Kabul-Delhi relations – something that can be true to an extent. On the other hand, it’s also a matter of fact that movies made by private companies don’t necessarily mean that they reflect a government’s policy. Moreover, the Indian government wouldn’t, hopefully, do so given the deep-knitted friendly ties and values the two states share. There is no doubt that in today’s world, cultural diffusion and propagation are done through social media and movies and in all fairness to India, it also wants to lionize their empires– perhaps at the expense of understating or insulting others. It’s expected of the country’s establishment to have carried out the required checks and inspection regarding the movie; because otherwise, this sensitive matter would result in damaging Afghans’ perception towards India and hurting the friendly ties between the countries. On the part of Afghans, they should stop wringing hands in worry because there is a famous quote by Nigerian Author, Chinua Achebe, which goes: “Until the lions have their own historians, the history of the hunt will glorify the hunter.” This analogy perfectly fits in the current situation as the Afghan side of the story is barely known while India glamorized theirs; therefore, in order to portray our history in our favor, our filmmaking companies should strive to achieve a status whereby they could make such movies to recount and glorify the heroic stories of Ahmad Shah Abdali.

Original Link:

Open Original News

More from Afghanistan Times

  • Prisoner exchange a good omen: Taliban 3 Hour

    AT News Report KABUL: The Taliban militant group has called the release of their prisoners in exchange for the two American University instructors as a good gesture and omen to facilitate the peace talks

  • Can’t recount votes in six provinces: IEC 3 Hour

    AT News Report KABUL: The Independent Election Commission has finished the process of vote recount in 15 of 34 provinces, saying that efforts are underway in another 13 provinces as well. However the IEC

  • IEC’s independency vital to prevent electoral crisis: Rana Think Tank 3 Hour

    AT News Report KABUL: The Rana Think Tank monthly participations believe that Afghanistan has once again at verge of electoral deadlock, which is not good for the country. The experts and political pundits

  • Tribal elders: Nobody can use name of Pashtoons in elections 3 Hour

    AT News Report KABUL: Elders from three zones have warned that nobody should use the name of Pashtoon ethnicity in the presidential elections. Hajji Din Mohammad, from Nangarhar province, alleged Tuesday

  • UNAMA interfering in Afghan elections: Mohaqiq 4 Hour

    AT News Report KABUL: Deputy of Chief Executive Office and a member of presidential candidate, Abdullah Abdullah’s team, Mohammad Mohaqiq said the presidential election has been engaged in crisis and

  • Two AUAF professors handed to US forces in Zabul 4 Hour

    AT Monitoring Desk KABUL: The Taliban freed two Westerners they had held for more than three years on Tuesday, in exchange for the release of three senior members of the Haqqani network, the New York

  • Hostages release help build peace confidence? 4 Hour

    AT News Report KABUL: The Taliban freed two Westerners they had held for more than three years on Tuesday, in exchange for the release of three senior insurgent leaders, officials said, in a deal that

  • Taliban rule left the country with few women healthcare workers: Feroz 4 Hour

    AT Monitoring Desk KABUL: Ferozuddin Feroz, Minister of Public Health speaking at the Reaching the last Mile forum at Louvre Abu Dhabi on Tuesday, said that there is a “missing generation” of women

Latest News: